Congressman Joe Barton should have listened to George Will before making his point about the Obama administration’s “shakedown” of BP.
Unlike Barton, Will doesn’t apologize to BP. Instead he clearly condemns BP’s abominable safety record. He makes the point that Barton tried to make, i.e. that Obama is using raw political power to confiscate $20 billion from a public corporation and even may make BP responsible for lost wages from Obama’s six month moratorium on deep water drilling.
Will makes the comparison to Venezuela’s Hugo Chavez who has frequently used government power to intimidate and expropriate businesses in Venezuela.
Will’s point is that we have laws and a judicial process to deal with BP.
The popular objection to this argument is that the legal process takes time and many Americans are suffering now. Nobody denies that. But it is adherence to laws and following due process that protects all Americans from abuse of government power. Some public opinion polls suggest that a majority of Americans support Obama’s bullying of BP. They need to understand that allowing any president to throw out our laws and legal processes for a shakedown at the White House, because we believe in the cause, creates a precedent that the government can then use to justify other threats against businesses and private citizens.
America has maintained a greater degree of freedom than any other country in the world for more than 200 years because it has adhered to Constitutional rules. Yes, this process has been imperfect and there have been other transgressions. But no violation of Constitutional government can be more serious than the Executive branch with its police and military power ignoring legal processes.
This is a key moment for the Tea Party movement which has appealed to popular opinion by focusing on Constitutional principles. What will Tea Party supporters advocate when popular opinion and Constitutional principles clash? The right approach is to stick with the Constitution and our legal processes and educate Americans on why this is so important. Hugo Chavez’ overthrow of Latin America’s oldest democracy is an appropriate case study that should serve as a warning to those who believe that anger at BP justifies ignoring the legal process.
{ 1 comment }
“…a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing” – William Shakespeare



